What's Driving The Yankees' Promising Pitching

The Yankees have given their fans plenty of reasons to be excited about the team’s potential this season. They currently own the best record in baseball at 42-19 and rank in the top five in almost every statistical category among individual players and teams. Aaron Judge and Juan Soto are already dueling for AL MVP, while Anthony Volpe has made a significant jump in his second year. All of these expectations were realistic among among fans before the season.

However, their pitching has emerged as one of the main factors toward their success. When reigning Cy Young winner Gerrit Cole was placed on the injured list for two months due to an elbow injury, the starting unit was faced with a steep task to produce in his absence. However, the team has responded in a big way. Starting pitchers, Carlos Rodon, Luis Gil, Nestor Cortes, Clarke Schmidt, and Marcus Stroman have all contributed which has resulted in a very balanced and effective rotation. They currently lead the league in wins and ERA while placing sixth or better in other pitching categories. 

The most successful of the bunch are Carlos Rodon and Luis Gil. Rodon signed with the Yankees in 2022 as one of the highest coveted pitchers in free agency. Although he dealt with injuries and inconsistent play last season, Rodon now looks like the big-time pitcher the Yankees envisioned him to be. He has allowed three or less runs in all but one game this season, and holds a 7-2 record. More importantly, Rodon seems comfortable handling the pressure of being a high-priced free agent for the Yankees.

"This doesn't feel overwhelming anymore," Rodon said after a win against the Chicago White Sox. "This feels like home which is nice. That makes a big difference."

Gil has been the biggest surprise in general for the Yankees. After playing sparingly in 2021 and 2022, he has made a significant impact in his first official season in pinstripes. Gil is tied for the team lead in wins, and his 1.99 ERA is the fifth best in all of baseball. That includes a .70 ERA in May that helped earn him AL Pitcher of the Month. His spectacular month also saw him make some franchise history by setting the rookie record for strikeouts in a game with 14 against the White Sox. 

https://x.com/BRWalkoff/status/1791903277707407752

Nestor Cortes hasn't quite resembled the all star he was back in 2022, but he has still bounced back from a disappointing 2023 season. Cortes' ERA has dipped from 4.97 to 3.46 and his strikeout-to-walk ratio is a career high 4.9. For Cortes to fully replicate his success from 2022, he'll have to find a way to string together solid performances on the road which is where he's struggled. 

Before ending up on the injured list with a lat strain, Clarke Schmidt was continuing to find proper footing in the starting rotation. After starting last season with a 2-6 record, Schmidt emerged as the team's second most reliable pitcher after Cole finishing with a 6-2 mark. This season, he was off to a fantastic start with a 5-2 record and a 2.52 ERA. If Schmidt can come back strong this season, he'll be a valuable piece on the back end of their starting rotation. 

Marcus Stroman has been exactly what the Yankees hoped he could be when they inked him in free agency this past winter. He is performing exceptional as the second starter in the rotation with a 5-2 record and 2.73 ERA. Some of Stroman's most productive outings have occurred without needing to strikeout batters as he leads the team in ground ball outs with 77. 

What is particularly impressive about the Yankees' starting rotation is their ability to succeed in different ways. On one hand, they have hard throwers like Gil, Schmidt, and Rodon whose go-to pitches travel beyond the average pitch speed, They also have guys like Stroman and Cortes' who throw below the average speed. In addition, they are able to get outs in various ways whether it's Gil's high strikeout rate or Stroman's ability to generate outs in the field.  

There are some questions to be desired such as whether Gil can continue to thrive in a bigger role. He saw limited action before this season so batters might not be well-prepared to face him. That could change as Gil gets more playing time. There will also be decisions to make in the back end of the rotation when Schmidt returns since Cole will be likely be healthy by then. Cortes undoubtably has the most impressive resume between him, Schmidt, and Gil, but he has also struggled the most out of the three this season. 

However, Cole's return will certainly ease some of those concerns regardless of how everything else plays out. In four years on the mound, Cole has been every bit of an ace for the Yankees leading the AL in wins, strikeouts, and ERA at least once with his Cy Young award serving as his latest accomplishment. If anything he should elevate the rotation because they have delivered in what has possibly been their most important stretch this season.